Large avatar vachelhoward

Vachel Howard, 56
Los Angeles, California
June 04, 2012

Agencies: Los Angeles Police Department California LAPD | 77th Street Community Police Station Jail Los Angeles California

Last updated: 6 months ago

Overview Help icon

Los Angeles police officers found reason to laugh after struggling with a schizophrenic man who died in their custody, new video showed Thursday.

The city paid the family of 56-year-old grandfather Vachel Howard a $2.85 million settlement after they filed suit over his June 2012 death at the LAPD’s 77th Street Station Jail.

The video of the fatal clash between Howard and several officers remained out of public view until ProPublica published the silent security camera footage Thursday.

It’s not clear why the officers were chuckling after a nurse examined the motionless Howard, then walked away to get her stethoscope. A lawyer for Howard’s daughter told the investigative news outlet that the video shows how unnecessary it was for him to die.
“Mr. Howard posed no threat whatsoever,” said V. James DeSimone. “He was down on the ground, six officers on top of him, no guns in the nearby vicinity executing a chokehold where there was no threat to the officers or to anybody else. It’s out of policy, it’s unlawful, and in this case it’s murder.”

The police department and the city attorney’s office, which negotiated the settlement last fall after two years of litigation, declined ProPublica’s request for comment.

The officer believed to have used the chokehold received a 22-day suspension. Other officers at the jail that day said they feared for their own lives.

Howard was arrested June 4, 2012, on charges of driving under the influence, according to a 2013 review by the Board of Police Commissioners. Police suspected he had smoked crack and marijuana and possibly taken PCP.

He told one officer after a strip search that he had a history of paranoid schizophrenia and had not taken his medicine recently. The officers described him as apparently hallucinating after his arrest but cooperative during the search.

The struggle began afterward, when police said he became agitated while handcuffed to a bench and advanced toward a nurse in the jail’s dispensary moments later.

Default user icon

Derrick Abernathy

Default user icon

Phillip Miller

Default user icon

John Daniels Jr

Default user icon

Arturo Cabrales

Default user icon

Dion Lamont Ramirez

Default user icon

Brenda Williams

Default user icon

Alex Jimenez

Default user icon

Brice Quintin Jefferson

Default user icon

Kenneth Lewis

Default user icon

Nahun Garcia

Default user icon

Juan Sanchez

Default user icon

Erik Garcia

Default user icon

Primitivo Macias-Rodriguez

Default user icon

Christian Chavez

Default user icon

Patrick Othro Sullivan

Default user icon

Robert Thomas

Default user icon

Justin Ford

Default user icon

Aaron Valdez

Default user icon

Aaron Borden

Default user icon

Gerardo Arvallo

Default user icon

Quentin Eric Hicks

Default user icon

Charles Anthony Curl

Default user icon

Jovon Antonio Talley-Ford

Default user icon

Christopher Coronel

Default user icon

Salvador Palencia-Cruz

Default user icon

Edgar Gonzales

Default user icon

Martin Osuna Aguilar

Default user icon

William Quiros Jr

Default user icon

Rickey Harvey

Default user icon

Juan Serna

Default user icon

Mario Vanegas

Default user icon

Elaine Coleman

Default user icon

Kenneth Bernard Williams

Default user icon

Deshawn Trenton Adams

Default user icon

Osvaldo Estrada Torres

Default user icon

Abraham Olivas Sanchez

Default user icon

Frank Filomeno Alejo

Default user icon

Christopher Moreno

Default user icon

Alphonse Edward Perkins

Default user icon

Darrell Atkinson

Default user icon

Victor Garcia

Default user icon

Juan Velasco

Default user icon

Carlos Edwin Arevalo

Default user icon

Salvador Zepeda Alarcon

Default user icon

Dennis Hakeen Vasquez

Default user icon

Ronald Boone

Default user icon

Jamar Witherspoon

Default user icon

Matthew Jerome Powell

Default user icon

Jose Carlos Perez Hernandez

Default user icon

Richard Tyson

Default user icon

Glen Boldware

Default user icon

Daniel Carlon

Default user icon

Paul Smith

Default user icon

Javier Orantez Chavez

Default user icon

Julian Nolasco

Default user icon

Marcellus Wright

Default user icon

Marco Gomez

Default user icon

Manuel Ramirez

Default user icon

Alejandro Erazo

Default user icon

Lee Dyrell Jefferson

Default user icon

Fernando Cortez

Default user icon

Jessie Long

Default user icon

Francisco Mondragon Saucedo

Default user icon

Hector Hernandez

Default user icon

Jose Millan

Default user icon

Jamie Flores

Default user icon

Brian Barbosa

Default user icon

Edmund Wong

Default user icon

Hernan Rubalcaba

Default user icon

Jose Solorio

Default user icon

Jorge Trejo

Default user icon

William Alexander Mejia

Default user icon

Daniel Ibarra

Default user icon

Juan Carlos Castillo Maldonado

Default user icon

Dale Garrett

Default user icon

William Lusk

Default user icon

Keith Watkins

Default user icon

Oscar Morales

Default user icon

Dnary Fowler

Default user icon

Ventura Saenz

Default user icon

Ricardo Badillo

Default user icon

Jose Luis Toloza

Default user icon

Felipe Valdovinos

Default user icon

Luis Alonzo Juarez

Default user icon

Arturo Yobani-Torrez Valdez

Default user icon

Brent McKinney

Default user icon

Roberto Fausto Rodriguez

Default user icon

Ruben Ramos Escobedo

Default user icon

Manuel Tovar Vargas

Default user icon

Maria F Ruvalcaba

Default user icon

Adebusola Tairu

Default user icon

Carlos Saenz

Default user icon

Sergio Acosta

Default user icon

Wilson Victorian

Default user icon

Jonathan Taylor

Default user icon

Anthony Michael Axe

Default user icon

Charlie Maurice Wilson

Default user icon

Shaun Conely Devell McCoy

Default user icon

Juan Noel Nunez

Default user icon

Ezequiel Jacobo

Default user icon

Reginald Andre Linthicum

Default user icon

Carlos Carrillo

Default user icon

Deautry Charles Ross

Default user icon

William Alfred Harvey III

Default user icon

John Rico

Default user icon

Alfred Longoria

Default user icon

Eduardo Hernandez

Default user icon

Frank Johnson

Default user icon

Carlos Wilhelm

Default user icon

Emiliano Amaya

Default user icon

Julien Robert Gonzalez

Default user icon

Wilford Hunton

Default user icon

Ilda Ebe Grasso

Default user icon

Sergio Sedillo

Default user icon

Antonio Tafolla

Default user icon

Marco Ernesto Avila

Default user icon

Oscar Lotari Romero

Default user icon

Zhonghua Li

Default user icon

Ernesto Castaneda

Default user icon

James Ramirez

Default user icon

Socrates Siqueiros

Default user icon

Pedro Gonzalez Santa Cruz

Default user icon

Christopher Allen Taylor

Default user icon

Guanda Denise Turner

Default user icon

Peter Rodriguez

Default user icon

Marcella Byrd

Default user icon

Jose Olguin Cabanas

Default user icon

Tien Hua

Default user icon

Alonso Cardenas

Default user icon

William Chau

Default user icon

Jonte Loven House

Default user icon

Frank Tranquilino

Default user icon

Moises De La Torre

Default user icon

Oscar Sermeno

Default user icon

Juan Herrera

Default user icon

Julio Sandoval

Default user icon

Xavier Gonzalez Torres

Default user icon

Manuel Soriano

Default user icon

Jairo Armando Pedraza

Default user icon

Byron San Jose

Default user icon

Marion Jose Habana

Default user icon

Alexander Accosta

Default user icon

Omer Garcia

Default user icon

Emmanuel Alvarez

Default user icon

Carlos Ornelas

Default user icon

Alberto Acosta Jr

Default user icon

Luis Salinas

Default user icon

Jose Torres

Default user icon

Eliuth Penaloza Nava

Default user icon

Victor Vidal Sigala

Default user icon

Cesar Antonio Limon Juarez

Default user icon

Delois Young

Default user icon

David Garcia

Default user icon

Christian Leonard Eaddy

Default user icon

Felipe Corrales

Default user icon

Anthony Aguilar

Default user icon

Jason M. Hendley

Default user icon

Jose Armando Cueva

Default user icon

Anita Gonzalez Delgado

Default user icon

Carlos Heredia Jr

Default user icon

Sergio Salazar

Default user icon

Robert Reagh Gillon

Default user icon

Noe Rene Escobar Reyes

Default user icon

Ruben Lamont Randolph

Default user icon

Jorge Ocon

Default user icon

Victor Francisco Tejeda

Default user icon

Lorenzo Cesar Aguilar

Default user icon

Miguel A Hernandez

Default user icon

Bong Chavez

Default user icon

Arturo Guzman

Default user icon

Jashod Arthur Carter

Default user icon

Jose Monteon Jr

Default user icon

Javier Ortiz