Large avatar escobar

Eli Eloy Escobar II, 14
Houston, Texas
November 21, 2003

Agencies: Harris County Sheriff's Office Texas | Houston Police Department Texas

Last updated: 4 months ago

Overview Help icon

14, h/m, (the only child of Lydia and Eli Escobar) shot in the head and killed by Houston police officer Arthur J. Carbonneau, a 4-yr. veteran, who claims he responded to a criminal mischief report and Escobar, standing in a group of boys, was pointed out to them by the caller. Carbonneau then claims a struggle ensued and his gun went off, killing the boy. But a friend of the boy said the two of them were playing video games inside the friend's apartment when officers came to the door and ordered them outside. When they didn't respond immediately, saying they didn't understand why they were being ordered out, Carbonneau grabbed Eli by his shirt and pulled him over to the fence. Eli fell to ground, he said, and told police he didn't do anything. Eli tried to get up and fell again. The friend said he then heard one gunshot. Carbonneau was indicted and convicted of criminally negligent homicide. His punishment: 6 months in jail and 5 years probation. He was also ordered to write a letter of apology to Eli's parents. Escobar is the 14th person known to have been shot to death this year by a Harris County police officer. In May, 2008, the City settled the civil case for $1.5 million, a letter from the city expressing condolences to Eli's parents, a commitment from the city to change gun handling and crisis intervention training for all HPD officers, and a memorial plaque in honor of Eli Escobar Jr.'s life to be placed on city property.

HPD officer Arthur Carbonneau. Convicted of criminally negligent homicide in 2005 for the 2003 shooting death of 14-year-old Eli Escobar II.; sentenced to 60 days in jail, 10 years’ probation. (media reports)

Legal Action Help icon

November 2004 officer indicted for murder

October 2007  Officer Arthur J. Carbonneau was found guilty of criminally negligent homicide

and sentenced to 60 days in jail and five years’ probation. He was allowed to resign from the department.

May 2008 $1.5million payout

Community and Family Efforts Help icon

November 2008 Memorial

Default user icon

Alejandro M. Santiago

Default user icon

Willie B Greene Jr

Default user icon

Hung Trieu

Default user icon

Alejandro Salazar

Default user icon

Fidencio Diaz Ramirez

Default user icon

Janie Goodwill

Default user icon

Sandra Gene Oliver

Default user icon

Latoshia Suzette Clark

Default user icon

Rossie Bonilla

Default user icon

Kathy Reeves

Default user icon

Mamie Laverne Staton

Default user icon

Flora Cornejo Puebla

Default user icon

Carlos Cabrera

Default user icon

Edelmiro Hernandez

Default user icon

Erica Rhena Tyrone

Default user icon

Shelvin Rowmane Williams

Default user icon

Veronica Hobley Leath

Default user icon

Juan Carlos Cuadra

Default user icon

Stephanie Hernandez

Default user icon

Francine Sonnier

Default user icon

Brian Crawford

Default user icon

Tony Berry

Default user icon

Lucille Espinosa

Default user icon

Laurian S Rova

Default user icon

Margarita Lozano

Default user icon

Monica Pruitt

Default user icon

Tenisha Lee

Default user icon

Frances Reed

Default user icon

Stephanie Goode

Default user icon

Etta Brooks

Default user icon

Candyce Labrie-Koba

Default user icon

Deborah Arocha

Default user icon

Patricia Moore Walton

Default user icon

Samantha Denise Romar

Default user icon

Cynthia Rogers

Default user icon

Biolet Green

Default user icon

Norma Rodriguez

Default user icon

Raymond Luther Allen Jr

Default user icon

Sharon Peters